What I wish I knew before Grad school #3

Your project will probably fail.


While discussing projects with my mentor some time ago, he shocked me by disclosing that typically the most arduous and hi-risk projects are given to the most inexperienced and least likely to succeed, i.e. graduate students.  Why?  Because the alternative is to give those projects to post-docs who have a lot more riding on their success in the lab.  Apparently, as Grad-students we  can ‘afford’ to fail…

Failure and risk are unavoidable in science and even more so in gradschool.  Now, there are several ways your project can shit-the-bed.

1)  The hypothesis can be wrong

2)  The discovery can be uninteresting

3)  The required experiments can be technically impossible

4)  you can get ‘scooped’

There are some things you can do to avoid having to dump years of hard work and start over, but I think the most important thing is to have a back-up.  It is critical to have a second project simmering on the back-burner in case your ‘main’ project tanks.  To make your life easier the projects should be related, but be careful that the death of one doesn’t pull the other to the grave with it.

Avoiding failure requires forethought, and lots of it.  For example, it is possible to devise a project such that the research is interesting and publishable whether your hypothesis is wrong or right.  For example, your data suggests that some interaction of proteins happens in a cell, a good project will be able to say ‘Hey, I found a novel interaction that does X’.   But if the data goes the other way it could say ‘Hey, X unexpectedly  happens without the interaction you would expect’.  It’s not always easy or possible to devise such a scenario, but it should always be looked for because it will greatly increase the security of your project.

Likewise, making sure your discovery is interesting requires discipline and forethought throughout the research process.  Finding an interesting molecular interaction inside of cells is great, but how great is it if in the end you discover that the result of that interaction is redundant and only marginally different from a process that has been shown ten times over?  To avoid this kind of situation I think it is best to either start with a solid and relevant (preferably clinically relevant) finding, and/or jump ahead to the punch line.  Figure out the clinical or biological significance (that people will care about) about your molecular interaction before teasing out all the details in between.  Real science, although presented as such,  is seldom linear.

Technical challenges abound in science.  If it were easy it would have already been done, wouldn’t it?  Going into a project that requires only techniques that are well established in your lab will save you lots of agony, frustration, and potential failure.  However, novelty is the drug of choice among scientists, so employing a novel technique will boost the interest and excitement of your project.  The key, I think, is to know what you are getting into.  Think about the  technical challenges you are creating when planning your project, try to limit them to a reasonable number, like one, and have an alternate method as a back-up.

Getting scooped is the great and perpetual fear of all researchers.  One day you’re knee deep in the throes of research, the next you see that someone published exactly what  you were working on, and did it better… The only sure fire way to avoid it is to alienate yourself from your friends and family, forget what ‘vacation’ and ‘holiday’ mean, and work your butt off 24/7.  However, while you may have little control over whether or not you get scooped, being aware of how competitive your field is will help you know how to pace yourself.  Highly competitive fields may require you to run closer to that line of burn-out, and you need to be prepared for that.

Lastly I’ll say that if your project bombs-out, please, don’t panic.  It happens to all of us all the time.  Take a day off to eat some ice cream, punch a bag, or question your sanity in deciding to go to gradschool, then come back to the lab and find your new quest.

What I Wish I Knew Before Gradschool

What I wish I knew before Grad School #1

What I wish I knew before Graduate School #2


About jaurelguay

I'm a Research Scientist, a Husband and Father, and Published Writer. View all posts by jaurelguay

5 responses to “What I wish I knew before Grad school #3

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

Because, Unicorns.

Adventures in Parenting, Family Blending, Loving, and Living.

Theo Taylor

Theo Taylor is a writer, fitness freak and college student who has been published by Thought Catalog, Asimov's and Aphelion. He writes star spanning science fiction and monster filled high fantasy. His debut novel ROGUE COSMOS will release in August, 2015. If he's not reading or writing, check the gym. He's almost always in the gym.

Killer Kitsch

Art, entertainment and pop culture blog for the discerning geek & nerd

Kin S. Law

Steampunk & Sci-fi-fantasy author


Wherewolves the Novel


Official site for author JD Spero

Just another blog, a place to share my inspirations, my writing, etc...


Writing Stories on the Hearts of Children

Spark: A Creative Anthology

Spark is a quarterly anthology accepting Poetry, Flash Fiction, Short Stories, and Creative Non-Fiction. We encourage both established and emerging talent.

Under a Starlit Sky

Flash Fiction & Short Stories

Tony's Thoughts

My opinions, my views. Nothing else.

Anika's Antics

The Official page of Anika Arrington. I write things. Some of them end up here.

here + now

let's talk . let's drink. let's live.


Steampunk music and the people behind it

The Daily Wordforge

Wordsmiths, tell stories.


Nate Silver’s FiveThirtyEight uses statistical analysis — hard numbers — to tell compelling stories about politics, sports, science, economics and culture.

The Dream Forge

by Anders Blixt, SF author and game designer


Blowing minds, melting faces, and pissing off The Man since 2009.

Protect Young Minds

Kids Can Learn to Reject Pornography

Rave Reviews By Nonnie Jules

Reviews Make an Author's World Go Round

How do we feed the world's starving

We feed billions of people in need, this is how.

The English Major's Blog

A blog for Sheila van den Heuvel-Collins: writer, editor and tutor


science | philosophy | thinking

Silly Robots

Writing Science Fiction was always this fun

Planetary Defense Command

Defending the planet from bad science fiction

From Researcher to Patient

My fight against acute myeloid leukemia...in the lab and in my own life.

The Torn Page - A K Hinchey's Writing Blog

Where fantasy and reality collide...

All Five Sisters

All five of us - together in one place!

one cool site

WordPress blogging tips & tutorials

Ben Ireland Books

Books by Ben Ireland

Nelson Literary Agency

Just another blog, a place to share my inspirations, my writing, etc...

Marian Rosarum

fairy tale and literary fantasy author

Scenes and Sequels

The writing and ramblings of David Kearney

Lori Lesko - BLOG

Just another blog, a place to share my inspirations, my writing, etc...


graphic designer, bibliophile, spoonie


tell a redemptive story with your life. now.


The Science Of Survival

Airship Ambassador

Information for the Steampunk Community - www.AirshipAmbassador.com


Just a shiny little place to dream.

Just another blog, a place to share my inspirations, my writing, etc...


Just another blog, a place to share my inspirations, my writing, etc...


Just another blog, a place to share my inspirations, my writing, etc...

Novel Conclusions

"We are all apprentices in a craft where no one ever becomes a master." - Ernest Hemingway

%d bloggers like this: